Giants / Bears (0-3) - DENIED

Bears get
Fred Robbins 87
Jerricho Cotchery 89

For

Giants get
Tommie Harris 95
3rd round pick (90 overall)

(nods head in approval)

Taking into account Harris's age, I think the 3rd round pick should be a lower one.

I am a no for now

cotchery is one year older! and at a much more important position once again. you guys are not taking into account how these players help our respective teams. they fill needs for both of us and make both of us much better off.

I think the pick should be dropped altogether, this trade would be just about perfect with just the players. Giants getting a top young DT + a rookie who should end up being mid 70's is too much. Drop the pick and I say yes. Or as said earlier, make it a later pick.

DENIED - AllMadden being the 3rd and final No vote.

both of us would really like to get this trade done, so I need to know what you value cotchery at. Cotchery would be 8 points higher than the bears current starting WR is quite young, and has a huge contract in place(something quite valuable in this league). His defense on the other hand is pretty good already and because this is madden not real life, the presence of tommie harris as his starting DT does not affect his overall team stats that much. Harris also has a deal ending soon, and this trade puts the burden of resigning points on me instead. With this being noted I don't understand how you can view this trade as unfair when the replacement he gets for harris is 87 overall(30 years old) and he gets a WR which he desperately needs. You acted like this trade was preposterous, yet accepted a 70 overall wideout, a 81 overall aging safety, and the last pick in the 2nd round for a 93 overall 24 year old WR.

RonMercer wrote:

both of us would really like to get this trade done, so I need to know what you value cotchery at. Cotchery would be 8 points higher than the bears current starting WR is quite young, and has a huge contract in place(something quite valuable in this league). His defense on the other hand is pretty good already and because this is madden not real life, the presence of tommie harris as his starting DT does not affect his overall team stats that much. Harris also has a deal ending soon, and this trade puts the burden of resigning points on me instead. With this being noted I don't understand how you can view this trade as unfair when the replacement he gets for harris is 87 overall(30 years old) and he gets a WR which he desperately needs. You acted like this trade was preposterous, yet accepted a 70 overall wideout, a 81 overall aging safety, and the last pick in the 2nd round for a 93 overall 24 year old WR.

All of us who responded replied that the 3rd round pick either needs to be a latter pick, or dropped. I could see nothing higher than a 5th round pick in it's place. If we vote no, we usually reply with our reasoning.

RonMercer wrote:

both of us would really like to get this trade done, so I need to know what you value cotchery at. Cotchery would be 8 points higher than the bears current starting WR is quite young, and has a huge contract in place(something quite valuable in this league). His defense on the other hand is pretty good already and because this is madden not real life, the presence of tommie harris as his starting DT does not affect his overall team stats that much. Harris also has a deal ending soon, and this trade puts the burden of resigning points on me instead. With this being noted I don't understand how you can view this trade as unfair when the replacement he gets for harris is 87 overall(30 years old) and he gets a WR which he desperately needs. You acted like this trade was preposterous, yet accepted a 70 overall wideout, a 81 overall aging safety, and the last pick in the 2nd round for a 93 overall 24 year old WR.

Only the 3 TC Members who voted No are allowed to give an answer to the following by RonMercer.

...However, my guess would be because Tommie Harris is basically the best DT in Madden. There isn't many DT's that can consistently get 9+ sacks a year in the game.