Giants/Patriots (0-3) - DENIED

Posts : 122 Join date : 2008-04-30 Age : 36

Pats get:
Plaxico Burress
Fred Robbins

Giants get:
Vince Wilfork
2nd rd pick # 31
3rd rd pick # 4
Kelley Washington

Posts : 162 Join date : 2008-05-01

I'm going to say no to this.

Plax is basically = Wilfork, Wilfork may carry a bit more leverage due to age however.
Then Washington + 2nd + 3rd is too much for Robbins.
Since the picks are so close together, I'd say drop one of them and it is passable, but for now the Giants are getting too much in return.

Posts : 122 Join date : 2008-04-30 Age : 36

I disagree, plax is rated 2 points higher than wilfork at a position MUCH MUCH more important in madden than DT.

Posts : 118 Join date : 2008-04-26

This trade is fine. We are both getting the value that we need on our teams. Lets get some more votes on this!

Posts : 270 Join date : 2008-04-27 Age : 35

If the Patriots eliminate the 3rd round pick from the trade, then I can accept. Until then, I am a no.

Admin Posts : 181 Join date : 2008-02-06 Age : 37

Spygate wrote:: If the Patriots eliminate the 3rd round pick from the trade, then I can accept. Until then, I am a no.

» Panthers - Patriots (1-3) - DENIED
» Giants / Bears (0-3) - DENIED
» Patriots
» Patriots Draft order:
» Cardinals/Patriots (3-0) - APPROVED