Panthers/Cardinals (3-0) - APPROVED

Carolina get
Kurt Warner (QB)
Edgerrin James (HB)

Cardinals get:
Ken Lucas (CB)
4th round pick
3rd round pick

Looking at the ages of all players, and taking into consideration the picks:

Ken Lucas + 4th round pick = Edge

3rd round pick = Warner.

I agree.

Just confirming that I have indeed made this deal!

Quote :

Vhawk413 wrote:

If your trades do not follow this format they will not be voted on by the trade committee. This is to make the trade committee's job easier so they do not have to search for anything to decide if the trade is fair or not.


So and So gets
(Player's Name) (Position) (Rating) (Age) (Contract Years) example
Adrian Peterson RB 94 22 years old 4 year contract

So and So gets
(Player's Name) (Position) (Rating) (Age) (Contract Years)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

As well, if you post a trade in pending, the TC will NOT vote on the trade till both parties come in and say they agree to it. After the two parties both say they agree to it, there is NO going back and say you do not want to do the deal anymore. If it is in Pending trades, and you say agree, it is final. There is no turning back

SoxNats08 wrote:

Quote :

Vhawk413 wrote:

If your trades do not follow this format they will not be voted on by the trade committee. This is to make the trade committee's job easier so they do not have to search for anything to decide if the trade is fair or not.


So and So gets
(Player's Name) (Position) (Rating) (Age) (Contract Years) example
Adrian Peterson RB 94 22 years old 4 year contract

So and So gets
(Player's Name) (Position) (Rating) (Age) (Contract Years)

------------------------------------------------------------------------

As well, if you post a trade in pending, the TC will NOT vote on the trade till both parties come in and say they agree to it. After the two parties both say they agree to it, there is NO going back and say you do not want to do the deal anymore. If it is in Pending trades, and you say agree, it is final. There is no turning back

We don't yet have the overall ratings and contract years since the Madden 09 game has not yet been released, but trading is open. The TC is going off of their expert knowledge of the NFL players on the game, and also probably off of the latest roster updates for Madden 08.

i agree

I am going to say

Lucas > Edge slightly, Edge sucked in real life, averaging 3.8 yards per carry I think, but Madden still seems to favor him, but I think Lucas will be rated slightly higher and is younger. but the position value of RB is more valuable than the CB

3rd and 4th < Warner slightly IMO. In real life, this would be too much IMO, but in Madden is about =, since Warner is old.

I can pass this

3-0 Yes

APPROVED.